Local Standards for Sample Size at CHI
Learning Facilitaton
/
Caine, Kelly
Proceedings of the ACM CHI'16 Conference on Human Factors in Computing
Systems
2016-05-07
v.1
p.981-992
© Copyright 2016 ACM
Summary: We describe the primary ways researchers can determine the size of a sample
of research participants, present the benefits and drawbacks of each of those
methods, and focus on improving one method that could be useful to the CHI
community: local standards. To determine local standards for sample size within
the CHI community, we conducted an analysis of all manuscripts published at
CHI2014. We find that sample size for manuscripts published at CHI ranges from
1 -- 916,000 and the most common sample size is 12. We also find that sample
size differs based on factors such as study setting and type of methodology
employed. The outcome of this paper is an overview of the various ways sample
size may be determined and an analysis of local standards for sample size
within the CHI community. These contributions may be useful to researchers
planning studies and reviewers evaluating the validity of results.
Designing Aging-In-Place Technologies to Reflect the Lifestyles and Precious
Artifacts of Urban and Rural Older Adults
Aging: A2 -- Older Users' Needs: Flying, by Lifestyle, and at Home
/
White, Ginger
/
Evans, Robyn
/
Connelly, Kay
/
Caine, Kelly
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 2014 Annual Meeting
2014-10-27
p.145-149
doi 10.1177/1541931214581031
© Copyright 2014 HFES
Summary: Technology has the potential to support aging in place to enable older
adults of all backgrounds to live with dignity and autonomy in their own home
for as long as they wish. However, perceptions, needs, and prototype
technologies are often studied using convenience samples of older adults
comprised of mid to high socioeconomic status (SES) individuals. Such
populations do not represent the individuals who may benefit most from aging in
place technologies, namely low-SES older adults. In this paper, we present
findings from nine 8-hour long contextual observations of low-SES older adults
living in rural and urban settings. We organize our findings and implications
around the themes of SES status, daily routines and home characteristics. We
highlight differences and similarities between rural and urban low-SES
populations and discuss implications for design including designing for
connection including creating 'heirloom technologies', and designing for
lifestyle including space, time, family and supporting rituals.
Human Factors Considerations in the Design of Wearable Devices
Product Design: PD4 -- Wearable Product Design
/
Motti, Vivian Genaro
/
Caine, Kelly
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 2014 Annual Meeting
2014-10-27
p.205-209
doi 10.1177/1541931214581381
© Copyright 2014 HFES
Summary: Wearable devices have great potential to support several application domains
ranging from medical and safety critical, to leisure and entertainment.
Wearable devices' solutions are promising, and extensive research has been
conducted in this domain since the early 90's. However most of these works
focuses on the feasibility of individual solutions. As such, the human aspects
are often neglected, which can decrease not only the acceptance levels for
novel devices, but also their sustained engagement. To facilitate the
consideration of human factors in the early design stage, we present and define
a list of 20 human-centered design principles. We explain how each principle
can be incorporated during the design phase of the wearable device creation
process. By adopting these principles, we expect practitioners to achieve
better wearable solutions, improving the user acceptance, satisfaction and
engagement for novel applications.
Wearable computing: a human-centered view of key concepts, application
domains, and quality factors
Interactive tutorials
/
Motti, Vivian Genaro
/
Kohn, Spencer
/
Caine, Kelly
Proceedings of 2014 Conference on Human-Computer Interaction with Mobile
Devices and Services
2014-09-23
p.563-564
© Copyright 2014 ACM
Summary: This tutorial presents a human-centered view of the state-of-the-art of
wearable computing. Considering scientific and industrial aspects, it provides
key definitions in the domain, goes through practical applications and use case
scenarios, and concludes with quality factors and best design practices. An
interactive component will aid participants to apply the theoretical concepts
presented.
Understanding the wearability of head-mounted devices from a human-centered
perspective
Eyewear computing
/
Motti, Vivian Genaro
/
Caine, Kelly
Proceedings of the 2014 International Symposium on Wearable Computers
2014-09-13
v.1
p.83-86
© Copyright 2014 ACM
Summary: Extensive efforts have been dedicated to developing wearables, but existing
solutions focus mainly on feasibility and innovation. Thus, although many
devices are named 'wearable', users face some wearability issues. Previously
adopted trial and error approaches have effectively produced wearables, but not
focusing on human factors. Through an extensive analysis of online comments
about head-mounted devices, this paper presents their problem space from a
human perspective. The analysis of online comments from existing and potential
users enabled us to identify key aspects of the wearability of head-mounted
devices, bridging the gap between design decisions and users' requirements.
From checking on to checking in: designing for low socio-economic status
older adults
Designing for older adults and demographic change
/
Arreola, Ingrid
/
Morris, Zan
/
Francisco, Matthew
/
Connelly, Kay
/
Caine, Kelly
/
White, Ginger
Proceedings of ACM CHI 2014 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
2014-04-26
v.1
p.1933-1936
© Copyright 2014 ACM
Summary: In this paper we describe the design evolution of a novel technology that
collects and displays presence information to be used in the homes of older
adults. The first two iterations, the Ambient Plant and Presence Clock, were
designed for higher socio-economic status (SES) older adults, whereas the
Check-In Tree was designed for low SES older adults. We describe how feedback
from older adult participants drove our design decisions, and give an in-depth
account of how the Check-In Tree evolved from concept to a final design ready
for in situ deployment.
How In-Home Technologies Mediate Caregiving Relationships in Later Life
/
Huber, Lesa Lorenzen
/
Shankar, Kalpana
/
Caine, Kelly
/
Connelly, Kay
/
Camp, L. Jean
/
Walker, Beth Ann
/
Borrero, Lisa
International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction
2013-07-03
v.29
n.7
p.441-455
© Copyright 2013 Taylor and Francis
Summary: In-home technologies can support older adults' activities of daily living,
provide physical safety and security, and connect elders to family and friends.
They facilitate aging in place while reducing caregiver burden. One of older
adults' primary concerns about in-home technologies is their potential to
reduce human contact, particularly from cherished caregivers. In this
exploratory in situ study, we provided an ecosystem of networked monitoring
technologies to six older adults and their caregivers. We analyzed the amount
and content of communication between them. The amount of noncomputer-mediated
communication did not decrease through the 6-week study. The content of
communication coalesced into four themes: communication about the technologies,
communication facilitated by technologies, intrusiveness of technologies, and
fun and playfulness with the technologies. Results suggest that in-home
technologies, designed with sensitivity to older adults' primary motivations,
have the potential to shape and tailor important relationships in later life.
Consumer engagement in health technologies special interest group
SIGs
/
Cheng, Karen
/
Caine, Kelly
/
Pratt, Wanda
/
Connelly, Kay
Extended Abstracts of ACM CHI'13 Conference on Human Factors in Computing
Systems
2013-04-27
v.2
p.2485-2488
© Copyright 2013 ACM
Summary: How do we keep consumers engaged in using health technologies? We welcome
all researchers and practitioners who are interested in this question to join
us for a spirited discussion, hosted by the CHI Health Community.
Opportunities for ubiquitous computing in the homes of low SES older adults
Posters
/
White, Ginger E.
/
Connelly, Katherine H.
/
Caine, Kelly E.
Proceedings of the 2012 International Conference on Ubiquitous Computing
2012-09-05
p.659-660
© Copyright 2012 ACM
Summary: Eight hour contextual observations have been conducted in the homes of 5 low
socioeconomic status (SES) urban-dwelling older adults. The purpose of the
observations was to understand the daily needs and challenges of older adults
in order to design appropriate technology that can allow older adults to
age-in-place (age at home). The long term goal of the study is to develop a
suite of age-in-place technologies tailored to the lifestyle needs of low SES
urban and rural-dwelling older adults. This paper presents initial findings and
discusses how this ongoing research will be used to inform the design of future
age-in-place technologies.
The effect of monitoring by cameras and robots on the privacy enhancing
behaviors of older adults
Living and working with service robots
/
Caine, Kelly
/
Sabanovic, Selma
/
Carter, Mary
Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Human-Robot Interaction
2012-03-05
p.343-350
© Copyright 2012 ACM
Summary: This paper describes the results of an experimental study in which older
adult participants interacted with three monitoring technologies designed to
support their ability to age in place in their own home -- a camera, a
stationary robot, and a mobile robot. The aim of our study was to evaluate
users' perceptions of privacy and their tendencies to engage in privacy
enhancing behaviors (PEBs) by comparing the three conditions. We found that
privacy concerns lead older adults to change their behavior in a home
environment while being monitored by cameras or embodied robots. We expected
participants to engage in more PEBs when they interacted with a mobile robot,
which provided embodied cues of ongoing monitoring; surprisingly, we found the
opposite to be true -- the camera was the condition in which participants
performed more PEBs. We describe the results of quantitative and qualitative
analyses of our survey, interview, and observational data and discuss the
implications of our study for human-robot interaction, the study of privacy and
technology, and the design of assistive robots for monitoring older adults.
Reconciling privacy with social media
Workshops
/
Lipford, Heather Richter
/
Wisniewski, Pamela J.
/
Lampe, Cliff
/
Kisselburgh, Lorraine
/
Caine, Kelly
Companion Proceedings of ACM CSCW'12 Conference on Computer-Supported
Cooperative Work
2012-02-11
v.2
p.19-20
© Copyright 2012 ACM
Summary: Social media is one way that individuals share information, present
themselves, and manage their social interactions in both personal and
professional contexts. While social media benefits have been examined in the
literature, relatively little attention has been paid to the relationship of
privacy to these benefits. Privacy has traditionally been framed as a way for
individuals to protect themselves from the consequences of too much information
disclosure. However, privacy can be a means to enhance social media outcomes
and is essential for coordinating cooperative relationships. In this workshop
we seek to: a) broaden the lens of social media privacy research to examine the
benefits and outcomes of interactional privacy as they relate to social media
goals; and b) discuss the design of social media interfaces that are responsive
to both relational and privacy needs.
Audience visualization influences disclosures in online social networks
Works-in-progress
/
Caine, Kelly
/
Kisselburgh, Lorraine G.
/
Lareau, Louise
Proceedings of ACM CHI 2011 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
2011-05-07
v.2
p.1663-1668
© Copyright 2011 ACM
Summary: One of the major concerns about online social networks (OSNs) is privacy. We
introduce visualization and numeric audience information as potential interface
solutions to the problem of privacy behaviors that are misaligned with privacy
preferences. Findings from a large experiment with participants of all ages and
from a broad range of backgrounds suggest that for both current and potential
users, augmenting an interface with a visualization or numeric display of the
audience helps people disclose in a way that is more in line with their own
preferences. We conclude by proposing that audience visualization and
quantification tools have the potential to assist users in achieving their
privacy goals while using OSNs and have the potential to enhance privacy in
other information systems as well.
Why it works (when it works): success factors in online creative
collaboration
Create, donate, collaborate
/
Luther, Kurt
/
Caine, Kelly
/
Ziegler, Kevin
/
Bruckman, Amy
GROUP'10: International Conference on Supporting Group Work
2010-11-06
p.1-10
© Copyright 2010 ACM
Summary: Online creative collaboration (peer production) has enabled the creation of
Wikipedia and open source software (OSS), and is rapidly expanding to encompass
new domains, such as video, music, and animation. But what are the underlying
principles allowing online creative collaboration to succeed, and how well do
they transfer from one domain to another? In this paper, we address these
questions by comparing and contrasting online, collaborative animated movies,
called collabs, with OSS projects. First, we use qualitative methods to solicit
potential success factors from collab participants. Then, we test these
predictions by quantitatively analyzing a data set of nearly 900 collabs.
Finally, we compare and contrast our results with the literature on OSS
development and propose broader theoretical implications. Our findings offer a
starting point for a systematic research agenda seeking to unlock the potential
of online creative collaboration.
Errors of Disclosure in Computer Mediated Systems
COMMUNICATIONS: C1 -- From Vocal Cords to Mobile Computing: Understanding
How We Communicate
/
Poole, Alan B.
/
Caine, Kelly E.
/
Fisk, Arthur D.
/
Rogers, Wendy A.
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 54th Annual Meeting
2010-09-27
v.54
p.512-516
© Copyright 2010 HFES
Summary: People frequently use information and communication technologies such as
cell phones and email to mediate the transfer of private information. Often,
this information is intended to be shared only with the recipient or
recipients, and, in turn, kept from everyone else. However, people sometimes
make errors when disclosing private information. These errors can occur when
the intended information is sent to an unintended person or persons, when
unintended information is sent to the intended person, or a combination of
both. Fifteen adults (aged 19-23) were interviewed using the critical incident
method to elicit past instances of erroneous disclosure. The interviewer sought
to understand the circumstances surrounding incidents of erroneous relays of
private information. Participants reported an average of 3.67 (SD = 1.59)
instances of erroneous disclosure, or misclosure per person. Most reported
errors involved email and other familiar technologies, with various
designed-based causes. These findings point towards specific design features
common to many information and communication technologies such as predictive
text and button proximity that may lead to erroneous disclosure.
Predicting successful completion of online collaborative animation projects
Posters
/
Luther, Kurt
/
Ziegler, Kevin
/
Caine, Kelly E.
/
Bruckman, Amy
Proceedings of the 2009 Conference on Creativity and Cognition
2009-10-26
p.391-392
Keywords: animation, leadership, online communities, online creative collaboration,
predicting success, social computing
© Copyright 2009 ACM
Summary: Online creative collaboration projects are started every day, but many fail
to produce new artifacts of value. In this poster, we address the question of
why some of these projects succeed and others fail. Our quantitative analysis
of 892 online collaborative animation projects, or "collabs," indicates that
the early presence of organizational and structural elements, particularly
those of a technical nature, can predict successful completion.
Sacred imagery in techno-spiritual design
Designing for other cultures
/
Wyche, Susan P.
/
Caine, Kelly E.
/
Davison, Benjamin K.
/
Patel, Shwetak N.
/
Arteaga, Michael
/
Grinter, Rebecca E.
Proceedings of ACM CHI 2009 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
2009-04-04
v.1
p.55-58
Keywords: HCI, design, mobile computing, spiritual computing
© Copyright 2009 ACM
Summary: Despite increased knowledge about how Information and Communications
Technologies (ICTs) are used to support religious and spiritual practices,
designers know little about how to design technologies for faith-related
purposes. Our research suggests incorporating sacred imagery into
techno-spiritual applications can be useful in guiding development. We
illustrate this through the design and evaluation of a mobile phone application
developed to support Islamic prayer practices. Our contribution is to show how
religious imagery can be used in the design of applications that go beyond the
provision of functionality to connect people to the experience of religion.
Supporting privacy by preventing misclosure
Doctoral consortium
/
Caine, Kelly E.
Proceedings of ACM CHI 2009 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
2009-04-04
v.2
p.3145-3148
Keywords: aging, disclosure, error, misclosure, older adult, privacy, technology
acceptance, ubiquitous computing
© Copyright 2009 ACM
Summary: Despite extensive concerns about privacy and multiple potential consequences
of revealing personal information, many users still experience invasions of
privacy when interacting with technology. For this reason, privacy is an
important and complex issue in HCI. This thesis focuses on specific
psychological issues of privacy in HCI, primarily the accidental disclosure of
information or misclosure. Using multiple methods including focus groups, a
diary study, and an experimental manipulation, this thesis seeks to catalog the
incidence of such errors, identify the interface issues associated with each
type of error, and provide design recommendations for preventing each type of
disclosure error.
Privacy Concerns and Disclosure Behavior in a Health Setting
STUDENT FORUM: SF2 - A Compilation of Innovative Student Research
/
Caine, Kelly E.
/
Burnham, Kaylee E.
/
Fisk, Arthur D.
/
Rogers, Wendy A.
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 52nd Annual Meeting
2008-09-22
v.52
p.1785-1789
© Copyright 2008 HFES
Summary: Health care practitioners need complete and accurate information to provide
quality care to their patients. However, health information is considered to be
highly private. Patients may have concerns about disclosing such information,
especially if asked to provide this information using technology. The goal of
this study was to investigate how participants' experience with a technology
affect their level of disclosure in a health setting. Specifically, we were
interested in understanding how the use of a health database system influences
the disclosure of private health information. We asked 12 younger and 12 older
adults to interact with a computerized health data entry system and then to
rate the completeness and accuracy of their intended disclosures. Results
indicate that, for the most part, participants would provide complete and
accurate information using such a system. Younger adults were less likely than
older adults to intend to disclose sensitive information, suggesting that
additional information gathering may be appropriate for younger adults. The
importance of providing a reason for the request of each piece of health
information is discussed in relation to the setting where information is
gathered.
Privacy and technology: folk definitions and perspectives
Works in progress
/
Kwasny, Michelle
/
Caine, Kelly
/
Rogers, Wendy A.
/
Fisk, Arthur D.
Proceedings of ACM CHI 2008 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
2008-04-05
v.2
p.3291-3296
© Copyright 2008 ACM
Summary: In this paper we present preliminary results from a study of individual
differences in privacy beliefs and relate folk definitions of privacy to extant
privacy theory. Focus groups were conducted with younger and older adult
participants who shared their individual definitions of privacy and engaged in
a discussion of privacy across six scenarios. Taken together, Westin's and
Altman's theories of privacy accounted for both younger and older adults' ideas
about privacy; however, neither theory successfully accounted for findings
across all age and gender groups. Whereas males tended to think of privacy in
terms of personal needs and convenience, females focused more on privacy in
terms of others, respecting privacy rights, and safety. Older adults tended to
be more concerned with privacy of space than information privacy. Initial
results suggest that designing for commonalities in privacy perceptions among
group members is feasible.
Sun dial: exploring techno-spiritual design through a mobile Islamic call to
prayer application
Works in progress
/
Wyche, Susan P.
/
Caine, Kelly E.
/
Davison, Benjamin
/
Arteaga, Micheal
/
Grinter, Rebecca E.
Proceedings of ACM CHI 2008 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
2008-04-05
v.2
p.3411-3416
© Copyright 2008 ACM
Summary: We present the design and formative evaluation of Sun Dial, an application
that supports Muslims' prayer practices. We report on a study that involved
identifying prayer as an activity that can be supported with technology; the
development of a prototype; and a short-term evaluation of Sun Dial conducted
with our local Muslim community. In addition to presenting a novel design idea,
our case study contributes to the growing corpus of research examining
technology and religion.
Benefits and Privacy Concerns of a Home Equipped With a Visual Sensing
System: a Perspective from Older Adults
AGING: A1 - Aging in the Real World: Practical Research Applications
/
Caine, Kelly E.
/
Fisk, Arthur D.
/
Rogers, Wendy A.
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 50th Annual Meeting
2006-10-16
v.50
p.180-184
© Copyright 2006 HFES
Summary: Monitoring technology has the potential to allow older adults to remain in
their homes longer than may otherwise be possible. However, often this
monitoring technology captures images which may cause privacy concerns,
especially when these images are captured in a home environment. We used Likert
scales within a structured interview to investigate privacy concerns in an
aware or smart home environment. Specifically, we were interested in how the
type of image that was captured and the level of functioning of the person
being monitored affected privacy concerns in a home environment. The data
suggest that both device type as well as level of functioning affect privacy
concerns in a variety of situations, providing the first evidence that certain
privacy concerns are not independent of situation variables.
Doctor-Patient Communication: Guidelines for Improvements
HEALTH CARE: Patients as Partners in Treatment
/
Hickman, Jamye M.
/
Caine, Kelly E.
/
Stronge, Aideen J.
/
Pak, Richard
/
Rogers, Wendy A.
/
Fisk, Arthur D.
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 50th Annual Meeting
2006-10-16
v.50
p.1078-1082
© Copyright 2006 HFES
Summary: Effective communication between patients and their healthcare providers is
essential to positive health outcomes. Older adults may be at a disadvantage
during communication exchanges due to age-related sensory declines and
cognitive changes. Understanding the role of these age-related changes may lead
to interventions that will ameliorate the disadvantages older adults face in
the health communication process. Twenty-four older adults were interviewed to
obtain an understanding of the difficulties older adults face during health
communication. The findings suggest that older adults do have health
communication problems. They are, however, able to generate strategies to solve
these problems when problems are presented in hypothetical scenarios. Based on
the findings, a brochure was developed to provide strategies and guidelines to
help anticipate and resolve health communication problems.
Acceptance of Computer Technology: Understanding the User and the
Organizational Characteristics
MACROERGONOMICS: Using Technology to Enhance the Organization
/
Park, Sung
/
O'Brien, Marita A.
/
Caine, Kelly E.
/
Rogers, Wendy A.
/
Fisk, Arthur D.
/
Van Ittersum, Koerts
/
Capar, Muge
/
Parsons, Leonard J.
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 50th Annual Meeting
2006-10-16
v.50
p.1478-1482
© Copyright 2006 HFES
Summary: A systematic analysis of acceptance of computer technology was conducted to
identify variables that would provide insight to understanding technology
acceptance. This led to a development of a comprehensive qualitative model that
captures the individual and the organizational user characteristics that
influence the acceptance of computer technology. This model suggests that
designers must be mindful of the role that sociological and organizational
variables play in technology acceptance. Such factors go beyond basic usability
issues in the design process. Attention to these variables may increase the
acceptance and therefore the diffusion of new computer technologies.
Understanding Acceptance of High Technology Products: 50 Years of Research
PRODUCT DESIGN: Tools, Technology, and Aesthetics
/
Caine, Kelly E.
/
O'Brien, Marita
/
Park, Sung
/
Rogers, Wendy A.
/
Fisk, Arthur D.
/
van Ittersum, Koert
/
Capar, Muge
/
Parsons, Leonard J.
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 50th Annual Meeting
2006-10-16
v.50
p.2148-2152
© Copyright 2006 HFES
Summary: This survey of research on acceptance of technology over the past fifty
years was conducted to identify and clarify those variables that influence
technology acceptance, particularly those that are related to aspects of the
technology itself. We surveyed the literature across many domains, selected
articles related to this research area, and coded these articles based on the
studied variables and products. The results of this survey are an
organizational schema for all of the variables as well as specific guidance on
the generalized effects of relevant variables such as perceived usefulness,
perceived compatibility, and perceived privacy. For each critical variable, we
discuss the implications to guide designers of high-technology products.
Age-Related Differences in Learning Incidental Environmental Information
AGING: Exploring Age Differences in Kinematics, Perception, and Cognition
/
Caine, Kelly E.
/
Nichols, Timothy A.
/
Fisk, Arthur D.
/
Rogers, Wendy A.
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 49th Annual Meeting
2005-09-26
v.49
p.190-194
© Copyright 2005 HFES
Summary: Incidental environmental information is consistent, potentially beneficial,
information that is not necessary for successful task performance (i.e., is
seemingly unrelated to the task). In the present study, older and younger
participants searched for target letters among distractor letters both of which
were laid upon color environments, such that certain color environments
predictively correlated with target letter location at varying degrees of
consistency. Neither group could express verbal knowledge of the pattern of the
environmental information although younger but not older adults showed improved
performance in conditions where incidental information cued target location.
The findings suggest that younger adults can benefit from incidental
environmental information even when they cannot express that it is present in a
task but that older adults may need additional cues to benefit from the
information.